Why this is Barry’s most important cup final since 1994


It’s one month today that we head into the cup final with The New Saints.

On 21 January 2017, Barry Town United take on perennial Welsh champions The New Saints in the MG Nathaniel Cup.

I’ve been a supporter of my home town club for well over 30 years. I’ve seen the Town play in a fair few finals over those 30 years, and I believe this is the most important cup final we’ve faced in well over 20 years.

Welsh Cup Final 1994

Like most Town fans of a certain vintage, I believe none of the finals are as memorable as the 1994 Welsh Cup Final which pitted Barry Town against Cardiff City at the National Stadium in Cardiff.

The Town went on to famously win 2-1, and the resulting hullabaloo launched the club into an ego-riddled money-led campaign to secure dominance in domestic Welsh football.  That dominance was secured within just 2 seasons.

Wars with the FAW

That 1994 Welsh Cup final appearance came after a long and bruising dispute with the Football Association of Wales (FAW) over our continued exile in the English Southern League. The club had returned to English competition in the early 1990s and had made a decent fist of it. The FAW wanted us in the new League of Wales, but we couldn’t see the point of it.


The only way we could remain in English competition was to physically remove ourselves from Wales. To this end, we set up the ‘Barri’ club in Worcester and took on the nickname of the Dragons and played in the Southern League as exiles for the 1992-93 season. Meanwhile, Barry Town AFC, remained at Jenner Park in the local leagues.

When the club controversially reversed its decision to remain in exile – mostly against supporters wishes – the club was allowed to enter the Welsh pyramid in the Welsh League Division One. In modern parlance, that’s Step 2 in the Welsh pyramid.

The club went on to lift the 1993-94 Welsh League title, and a slew of trophies including the treasured Welsh Cup.  It was our first Welsh Cup in almost 40 years, and only our second ever.


In our most recent dispute with the FAW, the club was pulled out of the Welsh League against our wishes, with the FAW seemingly powerless to prevent it.

The body that was running the football at Barry Town AFC quickly constituted itself as Barry Town United AFC in order to take up the inevitable position that would have been freed by Barry Town AFC.

The FAW had no time for us, our plight, or our argument.  Not only were we not allowed to enter Division One, we weren’t allowed anywhere the near the Welsh League itself.

Town fans’ memories of the previous dispute were fresh. When it suited the FAW, a reconstituted Barry Town was able to saunter into the Welsh League Division One. Now the same rules apparently meant we couldn’t. It was all bonkers. Eventually, the courts also decided it was bonkers, and the FAW were obliged to let us into the Welsh League.

Being the underdogs

The appearance at the Welsh Cup Final in 1994 saw us as underdogs to our English League cousins from Ninian Park.

In 1994, we had a wealth of Football League experience within our ranks, from David D’Auria to Alan Curtis. The only trouble was, their league careers were behind them. ‘Dad’s Army’ they despairingly called us in the very sniffy Cardiff-centric media.

The team to beat

The cup finals played after the Cardiff City final saw us as the dominant force, and the team to be beaten. This duly happened, somewhat ironically, at the same venue of the National Stadium, against the same opponents we face in January.

A Barry Town that had swept all before them came up against ‘plucky’ Llansantffraid – one of the previous names for the current New Saints club. We lost on penalties. After that, we won some, we lost very few, but we were never again the underdogs.

Back to being underdogs

Our final against The New Saints this January is arguably a bigger gap than when we faced Cardiff City. With our club’s lack of experience of cup finals (none since 2003), and the fact that The New Saints are still breaking records in the Welsh Premier League, we’re up against it.

The average age of the team we’ll put out in January will be about half the age of some of the players we put out against City.

This is no Dad’s Army.

That’s not to say we’re inexperienced. The backbone of our team have hundreds of appearances for us alone on their CVs. The whole club is up for this.

Whatever happens in January, this is absolutely the most important cup final we’ve played in over 20 years. We’re the underdogs, but we’re also a better club than we were in any previous final.

With youth teams, ladies teams, an academy, disability section, a domestic licence, and a one-club ethos, we’re stronger and hungrier than we’ve ever been.

MG Nathaniel Cup Final details: 

  • The New Saints v. Barry Town United, 21 January 2017 at 5:15pm
  • Cup final venue: Cyncoed Campus, Cardiff Met, CF23 6XD.
  • Tickets are available from the Jenner Suite, Jenner Park
  • Tickets are priced at £7 and £3 for concessions
  • Contact: davidjcole1948@yahoo.co.uk or @BarryTownUnited



Barry Villa

Barry Villa AFC

Barry Villa 1907-08

Winners of the Cardiff & District League 4th Division, 1907-08

TOP ROW: J.Curtis, A.Miles, F.Mayled, F.Johnson (secretary), E.J.Felix and J.Burt

MIDDLE ROW: D.Jenkins, E.Evans, F.Chaplin, C.Kingdom, W.L.Hughes (vice-president), H.Mogg, E.English, and W.Stokes

BOTTOM ROW: W.Price, W.Abbott, B.Burbidge (vice-captain), J.Burt (captain), F.Tippett, and J.James.














The Barry Woodvilles AFC

This picture of the Barry Woodvilles was featured in the  Evening Express  in December 1910

The Barry Woodvilles AFC were a Barry team that appear to have begun life playing in the Cardiff & District League 4th Division for the 1910-11 season.

A typical Woodvilles line-up would be:

Goal – W.Andrews; backs – T.Hunt, and T.English; half-backs – M.Pratt, J.Evans and H.E.Gale; forwards – L.Evans, H.Morris, W.Powell, F.Leay, and W.Gardiner

The club were still going in the immediate pre-Great War years, and was also of the clubs involved in the inaugural season of the ASRS Cup Competition of 1911-12, losing to eventual winners Barry Island AFC, in a 2nd Round replay in early 1912.

The line-ups often featured a W.Gardiner, and it is quite possible that this is the same W.H.Gardiner who later became the Secretary of the Barry & District Association Football League.

Dai Ward signs for Barry – legend status assured

The Football Express
Saturday 4 September 1926

That Ward, the recent acquisition from Aberaman, is regarded as an important capture to Barry was exemplified in both engagements. So impressed were both the directorate and spectators by this speedy, clean-limbed player’s brilliant performances that he is readily acclaimed as the best forward Barry has imported for several years.

The Football Express
Saturday 11 September 1926

One cannot praise too highly the performances of Ward, who has filled the pivotal position rendered vacant by the departure of Hopkins to Crystal Palace.

Not once in the engagement with Pembroke Dock did this enterprising young footballer allow a solitary wing-pass to escape him without making a real effort to turn it to good account.

So completely is he in possession of those material necessities which go to make a fine bustling forward that supporters fear that such a splendid exponent of the right class of football will not long escape the notice of those eagle-eyed and alert club managers who are ever anxious to ‘snap-up’ promising talent.

Ward is not one of those players whose ability is allowed to go a-begging for want of adequate support, for there was not a weak link in the home team

The Football Express
Saturday 2 October 1926

Serious concern has been occasioned amongst soccer enthusiasts at Barry at the knowledge that in consequence of a cut-head, sustained in colliding with a defender in the Mid Rhondda game, Ward, the popular Linnets’ forward, who has scored more goals in six weeks that any other player on the Barry books for many years past, was put right out of action.

It is hoped that his ‘knock’ will not incapacitate him for today’s game with Lovell’s Athletic at Barry, for without his aid the Linnets’ chances of qualifying for the 2nd Preliminary Round of the English Cup contest would be considerably minimised.

Final Score:
Barry 2 – 0 Lovell’s Athletic
(D.Ward, C.Brittan)

Ed: Dai Ward would go on to score 66 goals in the 1926-27 season, including TEN hat-tricks, assuring the club of an excellent mid-table Southern League position, the Championship of the Welsh League (leaving the ‘seconds’ of Cardiff, Swansea and Newport in our wake), as well as becoming winners of the South Wales Senior Cup. Ward had several hugely successful seasons at Barry before finally moving on – but by then, by coincidence, Barry had hired Fred Whitlow which is another goal-scoring sensation story waiting in the wings. Dai Ward’s son, Dai Ward Junior, also played for Barry Town – in the 50s – and went on to represent Wales.

A glimpse of the creation of Jenner Park: For the people, by the people

The Barry Association Club :

“A Host of Voluntary Workers”
South Wales Daily News
Saturday 30 August 1913

When the new Barry Association Football Club ground is opened a revelation will be made.

The playing pitch is level and the turf is in a healthy state. The amphitheatre-shape of the field and the erection of the dressing rooms and stands and other conveniences display the remarkable activity of the club officials, who have Mr. C B Griffiths at their head and Mr T H Hill as president of the Supporters’ Club.

A remarkable fact connected with the task is that artisans have been going their work free of cost, whilst the cost of the dressing rooms and a large proportion of the stands has been paid by means of two handsome donations. The Supporters’ Club have also provided the goal-posts, nets, and other necessary material.

It is no common occurrence to see masons, printers, carpenters, and dock labourers devoting their leisure hours to the service of the club, and this element augers well for the future.

The day 10,000 fans said ‘no’ to their match getting called off

The Barry Herald
Saturday, 19 September 1925

Barry v Mid Rhondda United
Referee forced to allow match to proceed

Angry scenes were witnessed at Jenner Park today, when in consequence of the referees decision to abandon the match, two huge crowds numbering over 10,000 raised a stormy protest and clamoured for admission.

When the referee first inspected the ground he was settled in his decision that the game would have to be postponed owing to the bad state of the pitch, but suspended his intention when some of the Barry directorate offered to sweep away the water with brooms.

This they did, while the two huge crowds at the Gladstone Road and Crogan Hill (Barry Road) ends patiently awaited the verdict. Eventually, upon the townspeople demonstrating, the referee reversed his decision.

(ED: The match at Ninian Park between Division One Cardiff City and Sunderland HAD been postponed, so Barry folk returned from Cardiff in time for our kick-off and were not best pleased when our match was going to get called off as well. Interestingly, across the country, because of the weather, games were either called off or had severely depleted crowds.

The 10,000+ crowd at Jenner Park that day was a larger crowd than that seen at several English League Division One fixtures, such as Birmingham v Notts County (5,000), Sheffield United v Blackburn (7,000), WBA v Bury (8,000) and equal with that of Burnley v Arsenal, and only slightly less than the 12,000 at Leeds v West Ham, and Bolton v Aston Villa. The attendance at Anfield for Liverpool v Manchester United was 18,000, while Newcastle had the biggest attendance of 25,000 for their match with Leceister.

The attendance is even more extraordinary when you consider we had already played Mid Rhondda United in the Southern League twice already. But this was the 1st Qualifying Round of the FA Cup. This match ended in a 2-2 draw with our goals scored by Hopkins and Dai Collier. The Replay also ended in a draw, but the 2nd replay saw us edged out 2-1 in Tonypandy.

Amazingly, that wasn’t the end of it. We were drawn against them in the Welsh Cup 3rd Round, and after we held them 4-4 at theirs, we beat them 4-3 in the Replay. By the time this was settled, we had played Mid Rhondda United SEVEN times by the January.

Here are those stats:

02 Sep 25 : Mid Rhondda United (H) League 2-1 : W
14 Sep 25 : Mid Rhondda United (A) League 0-1 : L
19 Sep 25 : Mid Rhondda United (H) FA Cup 2-2 : D
23 Sep 25 : Mid Rhondda United (A) FA Cup 2-2 : D
26 Sep 25 : Mid Rhondda United (A) FA Cup 1-2 : L
13 Jan 26 : Mid Rhondda United (A) W. Cup 4-4 : D
27 Jan 26 : Mid Rhondda United (H) W. Cup 2-1 : W

…and that’s not including our Welsh League teams meeting twice during the season as well.)

Old Barry in Pictures (Facebook)

I don’t do Facebook, but recently a photograph has been sent in to the excellent Old Barry in Pictures Facebook page that requests information on a photograph that has been submitted.

Here is the photo (used, hopefully, with permission)

The Barry Schoolboys Football Team (1916)
The Barry Schoolboys Football Team (1916)

I believe the photograph to be that of the Barry Schoolboys, who defeated the Cardiff Schoolboys at Ninian Park in May 1916 to win the Welsh Schools Shield.

The Final was originally held at Jenner Park, Barry, but with the game ending in a 1-1 stalemate, Ninian Park was the scene of the Replay.

J.Weston (Barry Island School) got the opening goal after 25 minutes, but when Pearce equalised for the Cardiff Schoolboys, the game again ended 1-1. The match went to Extra Time and the Barry Schoolboys were ultimately awarded a penalty which was scored by E.Griggs (County School), the captain, to give the Barry lads a 2-1 win. It was the fourth time Barry Schoolboys had won the Welsh Schools Shield.

The winning line-up was : W.Forbes (Holton School), Glyn Martin (County School), W.Perry (Hannah Street School), J.Johnstone (County School), E.Griggs (County School), I.Hayward (Holton Road School), J.Weston (Barry Island School), S.Cruise (Holton Road School), J.Phillips (Holton Road School), Trevor Evans (County School), and W.Davies (County School).

I’m afraid I don’t know if these names bear any correlation to the photograph, but it would be great to be able to put names to faces.

The Welsh Schools Shield competition had started several years before, in 1913, with Barry Schoolboys winning the first title, and again in 1914, losing out to Cardiff Schoolboys in 1915, before reclaiming it in 1916. Indeed, Barry Schoolboys would win the title five times in the first seven years of the competition existence.

There were four Barry lads selected to play for Welsh Schoolboys against England Schoolboys at Bolton in 1916, prior to the domestic final: Glyn Martin, E.Griggs, S.Cruise, and W.Davies. Barry schoolboys had a fine history in Welsh International Schoolboy football with Barry boys featuring in the side since the inception of games with England Schoolboys in 1907 at Walsall.